Jagan Mohan Reddy faces criticism over show of strength during visit to injured student at Manipal Hospital
YSR Congress Party president and former Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Y.S. Jagan Mohan Reddy has drawn criticism over the manner in which his visit to Manipal Hospital, where the Class 10 student injured in the Raptadu classroom attack is undergoing treatment, unfolded.

The student was critically injured after a man allegedly attacked her with a chainsaw inside her classroom in Raptadu, Anantapur district, on October 31. She was shifted to Manipal Hospital in Bengaluru for specialised treatment. Her condition has since shown encouraging improvement, with Education and IT Minister Nara Lokesh confirming that she has been extubated, is awake and responsive, and is recovering.
Jagan Mohan Reddy visited the hospital to enquire about the student's health and meet her family. However, the scale of the gathering accompanying him and the scenes within the hospital premises triggered criticism from sections of the public and political observers. Critics questioned whether a visit to a hospital treating a critically injured child should become an occasion for a political show of strength.
The criticism has centred on the contrast between the two approaches to communicating about the student's recovery. Lokesh has been sharing brief medical updates, expressing gratitude to the doctors and conveying the government's support for the family. Critics argue that Jagan's visit appeared more focused on political optics than on the purpose of enquiring about the child's health.
The incident has also renewed discussion about the need for political leaders to exercise restraint when visiting hospitals, particularly when patients are critically ill and families are coping with a traumatic situation. Hospital premises must remain conducive to treatment, patient privacy and the smooth functioning of medical teams.
While political leaders across parties have the right to visit and express solidarity with the family, the priority in this case remains the student's recovery. Any assessment of the competing political claims should be separated from the medical team's efforts and the child's ongoing treatment.