Pinarayi Vijayan questions legality of former Governor Arlekar’s move to remove Keralam PSC chief
Leader of the Opposition Pinarayi Vijayan has questioned the constitutional validity of former Governor Rajendra Vishwanath Arlekar’s recommendation to remove Keralam Public Service Commission (PSC) chairman M.R. Baiju and the commission’s members, demanding that the state government clarify its position on the matter.

The controversy erupted after Lok Bhavan sources revealed that Arlekar had written to President Droupadi Murmu seeking the removal of Baiju and the commission’s 15 members over alleged irregularities in recruitment examinations. The recommendation was reportedly sent around October 15, shortly before Arlekar was relieved as Governor of Keralam on October 23 following his transfer to Tamil Nadu.
Vijayan argued that the removal of a PSC chairman or member must follow the procedure prescribed under the Constitution.
Citing Article 317, he said the President could remove a PSC chairman or member on grounds of misbehaviour only after the Supreme Court conducted an inquiry and recommended removal. He maintained that no such inquiry had been conducted against the Keralam PSC members.
He also invoked Article 163, arguing that the Governor was generally required to act on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers, except in matters where the Constitution provides for discretionary powers.
Vijayan described the recommendation as an alleged misuse of constitutional authority and called on the United Democratic Front (UDF) government to state clearly whether it supported the former Governor’s action.
He further argued that PSC members serve fixed terms and that the commission should not be subjected to wholesale changes based on political considerations.
The development comes amid a Crime Branch investigation into alleged irregularities in a PSC examination conducted in July 2023 for senior posts in the State Planning Board.
The investigation concerns an evaluation lapse in which questions carrying substantial marks were reportedly left unevaluated. The probe was subsequently expanded to examine allegations involving other recruitment examinations conducted by the commission.
According to reports citing investigation details, the lapses affected answer scripts submitted by candidates in the examination, raising questions about the preparation of the resulting rank list. The PSC has disputed aspects of the allegations, and the investigation remains a separate process from the constitutional question surrounding the removal of its members.
Lok Bhavan sources said Arlekar sought information from the commission’s vigilance wing and examined police investigation reports before sending his recommendation to the President.
Health Minister K. Muraleedharan backed action against the commission, citing the alleged irregularities and arguing that the recruitment body’s functioning required scrutiny. He also criticised the previous LDF government over the commission’s performance.
LDF convenor T.P. Ramakrishnan, meanwhile, opposed the recommendation, arguing that it threatened the independence of a constitutional institution.
The President has the authority to remove PSC members under the constitutional framework, with Article 317 prescribing a role for the Supreme Court in inquiries into allegations of misbehaviour. Arlekar’s recommendation does not, by itself, remove the chairman or members.
The dispute has now raised two distinct questions: whether the recruitment allegations warrant action against the PSC leadership, and whether the steps taken to seek their removal comply with the constitutional procedure.